Mystery surrounds the death of 20-year-old dancer Sarah Butler

12/8/2016, midnight
Police have yet to find the person responsible for killing 20-year-old Montclair, N.J., college student and dancer Sarah Butler, who ...
Sarah Butler Contributed

Police have yet to find the person responsible for killing 20-year-old Montclair, N.J., college student and dancer Sarah Butler, who was found dead at the Eagle Rock Reservation last Thursday after being reported missing days before Thanksgiving.

Butler’s body was found on the Eagle Rock Reservation, a 408-acre park known for its hiking trails and 9/11 memorials. Butler was driving a 2007 Dodge Caravan that was found abandoned in Orange, N.J., the night before.

Her friends and family were searching Montclair and surrounding areas for a week before she was found. Missing person flyers with Butler’s description were placed all around Montclair, as well as around the campus of New Jersey City University where Butler attended.

Authorities have officially ruled Butler’s death a homicide. Mystery still surrounds the manner in which she was killed. Questions as to why Butler was at the reservation and who ended her life are still unanswered. The Essex Prosecutor’s office has yet to disclose how she died.

“This is an active investigation; there are no updates at this time,” Chief Assistant Prosecutor Thomas S. Fennelly told the Amsterdam News.

Family and friends continue to mourn the loss of the Butler. “Not my Sarah, not my Sarah,” her mother LaVern Butler told ABC News7. “It was senseless I just … whoever did this is a dog.”

“We had trouble getting [the information] out there,” Butler’s father told Pix11. “If more news media had gotten the word out, then maybe we could’ve done something. Who knows.”

Butler was a passionate dancer and attended Premiere Dance Company for 17 years. She had performed at the Apollo Theater several times and danced with Montclair High School Dance Company.

Shirlise L. McKinley, a founder and director at Premiere Dance Theatre, remembers Butler as a “stellar and outstanding student.” McKinley told The Record North Jersey, “She was a lover of dance and always passionate about learning new things. We loved Sarah and she loved being at Premiere. This is such a tragedy.”

Butler was a hard worker, juggling school and a position at the YMCA. Jo Ann Short, president and CEO of the YMCA of Montclair, released a statement on their official Facebook page.

Short began, “Some of you may have heard that one of our former employees, Sarah Butler, who was a lifeguard at the Park Street Branch of the YMCA of Montclair, went missing Tuesday, November 22. When we learned from this morning’s news that her body was found in West Orange, we were devastated. As a 20-year-old college student, she had a bright and promising future ahead of her. The mystery behind her disappearance and ultimate loss of life is unsettling.”

She continued, “Her family is grieving and we pray for answers so their healing can begin. They are active members with us and part of our Y family. Sarah’s passing is a reminder to us all that life is precious and should never be taken for granted.”

Donna Crosson Greco, a colleague of Butler’s at the YMCA, expressed her grief over Sarah’s death. “I worked with Sarah—we taught swim lessons together. I remember her as pretty, smart and talented,” Greco told the Amsterdam News. “She was so good with the kids and made them feel like they could do anything. This is tragic, a terrible loss. My heart breaks for her family. I can’t imagine losing a child.”

A memorial was held Friday outside Butler’s Montclair home. A beautiful display of candles and flowers was set up in front of the home where she lived with her parents and two sisters. Friends and classmates held a vigil at New Jersey City University to honor the slain student.

A GoFundMe page was established by Elaine Wynn Boghosian, a close friend of the family, to aid the in the funeral costs. The campaign has surpassed its goal of $10,000, raising $11,175 for Butler’s family.

“We set up this GoFundMe account to raise money to support her family and help cover funeral and all unanticipated expenses associated with this senseless homicide,” wrote Boghosian on the campaign’s page. “This has been an incredibly difficult time for Sarah’s family, so we ask you to please open you hearts and help the family in their time of need.”

A reward of up to $10,000 is being offered by the Essex County Sheriff’s Department for information that leads to an arrest and conviction in the case.