At age 64, Joyce “Joy” Powell has spent her life wearing different hats: Hairdresser, pastor, musician, and mom of five; a drug dealer who harmed her community and an activist who tried to heal it. For now, she is content with a logoless yellow cap, which she pairs with a brown sweater and a leopard-print scarf over prison greens when she hears her photo will be taken. Powell knows she is many things. But she maintains she is no killer.

Joyce Powell, wearing a tan cap, tortoiseshell glasses and a leopard-print scarf, smiles at a table covered in papers.
Powell in the visiting room at Bedford Hills. (Photo by Shannon Chaffers)

The courts disagree. A jury convicted her on a second degree murder charge in 2011 for a cold case dating back to 1992. Powell is serving a 25-to-life sentence at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in Westchester County, the state’s only maximum security prison for women, where she met with the AmNews.

A vehicle passes the yellow State of New York sign for Bedford Hills Correctional Facility.
Van passes entrance to Bedford Hills Correctional Facility, Wednesday, Nov. 15, 2023, in Bedford Hills, N.Y. Year-long suspension of legal time limit to sue over sexual assaults against adults in New York has led to tidal wave of claims on behalf of women who were incarcerated. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

Powell navigated the interview with an open, friendly demeanor, quick to flash a wide grin even as she recounted a life marked by hardships: growing up in an abusive household, leaving the negativity of the streets, losing two sons, and spending the latter quarter of her life incarcerated.

She came prepared, blanketing the visiting room table with stacks of legal documents and newspaper clippings. The case documents tell the tale of her decades-long struggle for freedom, including her latest effort: a 102-page clemency petition to Gov. Kathy Hochul.

“In 2024 and 2025, the governor’s designee wrote me and said that I should file clemency on August 15, 2026,” says Powell, scything through the paperwork. “When August the 15th, 2026 came, I was trying to get letters as well from some of the [Department of Corrections and Community Supervision] employees because I felt like that would be more impactful for people that see me and know me [with] how I am on an everyday basis instead of saying ‘please give me clemency, I’m so good.’”

Legal papers, a handwritten note and newspaper clippings spread across a table, including one with a photo of Rev. Joy Powell.
Documents Powell brought to an interview with Amsterdam News at Bedford Hills. (Photo by Shannon Chaffers)

The news articles detail her life as an activist, recounting how she championed anti-violence and police accountability efforts in Rochester throughout the late 1990s and early 2000s. The community she forged through her activism — which she has continued while incarcerated — has come out in force to support her clemency application.

“[She] has an incredibly broad community of supporters, which is a testament to how many lives she touched before her incarceration, and a testament to how many people she has supported while she’s inside,” said Nathan Yaffe, a lawyer who prepared the application.

“Governor Hochul can free her today.”

Nathan Yaffe, attorney who prepared the clemency application

With her appeals of the conviction unsuccessful so far, experts view clemency as Powell’s best chance of being released from prison before she becomes parole-eligible in 2045. By that time, she will be 83.

Today64years old
Earliest release83years old

“It’s dangerous at this point for people like myself [who have] aged in prison. I’m 64, and I have aged tremendously,” Powell said.

A guard tower behind razor-wire fencing at the entrance to Bedford Hills Correctional Facility.
Guard tower near entrance to Bedford Hills Correctional Facility, Wednesday, Nov. 15, 2023, in Bedford Hills, N.Y. Year-long suspension of legal time limit to sue over sexual assaults against adults in New York has led to a tidal wave of claims on behalf of women who were incarcerated. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

At least four women have died while incarcerated at Bedford Hills this year, including two suicides, according to the Correctional Association of New York (CANY), a state-contracted watchdog. The prison has long faced federal scrutiny for sexual assault rates that are among the worst nationwide, and it now faces a fresh host of concerns.

In August, Sumeet Sharma, director of the CANY policy and communications team, said that a reduction of out-of-cell time and programming is worsening conditions, although he could not directly correlate these changes to the mounting death count.

“If you look at the period between 2020 and 2024, you’re seeing the prison have either one death or no deaths each year,” said Sharma. “Compared to the last two years where you saw three deaths in 2025 and four [so far] in 2026. Just incredibly concerning that there’s a clear increase in the number of people who are dying at Bedford Hills.”

Deaths at Bedford Hills

0–1each year
2020–2024
32025
42026
so far
Source: Correctional Association of New York (CANY), as cited by Sumeet Sharma

Yaffe said Powell’s age adds urgency to her case.

“She should get clemency because of who she is. She should get clemency because of the impact of the violence of incarceration in general and on her. She should get clemency because her community and her family need her home,” he said.

Early Joy

Born in 1962, Powell split time growing up in Brooklyn, Rochester, and Florida. She recalled a tough childhood and a fraught relationship with both parents, particularly her father, who she says was abusive. Her mother regularly fled New York City and took Powell to Rochester, where deep roots eventually formed.

By the time she reached early adulthood, Powell fell into the drug game. It was a time she is not proud of. She was not exactly slinging for survival, either — she owned a hair salon and a record studio under her label Joy and Pain Entertainment. As she puts it, she suffered from a “money addiction.”

The life eventually caught up to her. In the early-mid 1990s, she spent roughly three years incarcerated in the medium-security Albion Correctional Facility for drug trafficking. Her time there was traumatic, because she allegedly was raped and stalked by a corrections officer. However, she also got her first taste of activism, speaking out against what she described as a widespread culture of sexual abuse at the prison.

After her 1995 release, Powell returned to the same streets with newfound purpose. She started addressing her childhood trauma through therapy and began advocating for mental health awareness. Then, a teenager was killed outside her hair salon. “I realized he was 15 years old and he used to play with my children,” Powell recalled.

Joyce Powell, in a pink cardigan and patterned head wrap, smiles while seated in front of a winter backdrop.
Joyce Powell. (Courtesy of Jay Coffee)

The tragedy inspired her to get involved with anti-violence programs around Rochester. The same salon became a sanctuary for Rochester’s youth, and Powell re-emerged as a pillar of the community. News media, police, and local electeds soon took notice. She joined the Rochester Challenge Against Violence, a city program that supported at-risk youth.

“I started seeing it on a whole other level, where a lot of the children that were a part of the program — they were left to fend for themselves out there in the street,” Powell said.

She organized activities to keep them occupied and give them purpose.

“[I thought], ‘Let me have the kids write what their pain is …’ The kids would write songs. They would perform at neighborhood centers, schools, and everything,” Powell said. “The neighborhood bodegas would come say, ‘Hey, get this child, this little devil.’ I said, ‘Don’t call them the devil’… I started having them to clean in front of the stores and then I would get the mayor’s office to bring trash cans and rakes and brooms and all kinds of stuff.”

Her efforts became even more personal when Powell lost one of her sons, David Wright, to gun violence in 2001, said another son, Gregory Blake.

“She began to go out and do candlelight vigils when other teenagers were killed and [do] marches and protests for nonviolence,” said Blake. “I [had] seen her transition into that part of her life … she’s a great, resilient woman that really loves the community. She loves kids, and she’s all for justice.”

Powell’s advocacy evolved in August 2002, when she got a call from one of the youths she was working with. “Pastor, please come to Wegmans. The police killed my father’s friend,” she recalled the youngster saying.

The man killed was named Lawrence Rogers. He experienced a mental health crisis when officers from the Rochester Police Department forcefully arrested him, with one of the officers kneeling on his neck. He later died in the hospital from asphyxiation.

Rogers’s death shaped Powell into a prominent voice against police violence. In the immediate aftermath, she rallied her neighbors and took to the streets, protesting outside the precinct where the officer who killed Rogers was stationed. The protests reportedly continued into November in freezing rain.

In the following years, Powell and her bullhorn became a familiar sight as she called for removing officers from mental health-related calls. She also started courtwatching and grabbed a police scanner from an electronics store to track responses.

Still, Powell never fashioned herself against all cops. She often promoted stricter gun laws and preached cooperation with police. In October 2005, Powell and fellow advocates marched against violence and encouraged the community to come forward. They demanded that local shops stop selling shirts that said “Stop Snitchin.”

“It’s not snitching if you are getting crime off the streets,” Powell told the Democrat & Chronicle newspaper at the time.

Little did she know, a figure from her past was simultaneously feeding the authorities information that implicated Powell in a 1992 cold case murder.

The People v. Powell

Roughly a month after that rally, a jailhouse informant spoke with investigators and prosecutors at the Orleans County District Attorney’s Office regarding the 1992 killing of John Rutledge. He claimed to be in the car with Powell and another man, who the informant said pulled the trigger.

The informant’s motivation: “to deal away criminal charges he is currently facing from the correctional facility,” according to a state police report. Previously, the informant also called Powell on a phone tapped by law enforcement in a failed attempt to obtain a confession.

Police arrested Powell the next fall, but not for the murder: She was charged with burglary, assault, and criminal mischief after someone said Powell and five others attacked her. Powell, then in her mid-40s, claimed that the arrest stemmed from speaking out against police violence. She says a police officer had warned her against continuing her activism earlier in the year.

“He said … I just want to warn you that you shouldn’t be doing any more protests against police brutality. Not in Rochester,” Powell claimed.

According to the Democrat & Chronicle, the victim of the assault suffered injuries, including a fractured vertebra, and identified Powell as one of her attackers. The incident occurred on a Sunday. Powell provided an alibi stating that she was attending bible study at the time and argued that there was no DNA evidence against her.

A Monroe County jury ultimately found Powell guilty of burglary and assault in May 2007. Her background as a pastor and high-profile activist was explicitly barred from her defense, according to Essence magazine. She ultimately faced 16 years in prison for the conviction. Despite the lengthy sentence, she was scheduled to come home by 2023 — until the other shoe dropped.

In December 2009, Powell was serving out her first few years when Orleans County prosecutors charged her and a co-defendant with murdering Rutledge. The allegations painted a 1992 drug-related killing, with the victim owing Powell money and her or the co-defendant subsequently shooting him.

Court documents show that prosecutors used the informant’s testimony to place the defendants at the scene, even though they called him “one of the most psychedelic pieces” in the case.

Powell pleaded not guilty. A trial was held in May 2011 in Orleans County, a majority white and Republican region that includes portions of the greater Rochester metropolitan area. The prosecutors alleged that Powell, her co-defendant, and the informant traveled to Albion, the county seat, where they picked Rutledge up at a bar on the night of June 5, 1992. They then drove to a remote road, where prosecutors alleged Rutledge was shot and killed outside the vehicle. The informant testified that he remained in the car, and heard gunshots from the back seat.

According to court records, ten days after the body was found, police pulled Powell over in nearby Ontario County for a missing front license plate. The informant was one of the passengers in the car. The co-defendant was not. When the officer learned during the stop that the registration was suspended, he searched the vehicle. The inventory ultimately included bullets, a .38 Special Charter Arms revolver, and cassette tapes. Officers towed the vehicle. The firearm was sent to a state police lab in Albany for further analysis.

A state police investigator combed both the crime scene and Powell’s car for evidence. He found no DNA linking Rutledge to the vehicle. No latent prints belonging to him turned up when the car underwent a fingerprint examination and no bloodstains were found in the cabin. A generic earring back was found in the vehicle, but investigators could not determine whether it was the one missing from Rutledge when his body was found. However, a state police firearms examiner matched the ballistics to the gun seized from Powell’s car, concluding that the bullets that killed Rutledge were “beyond a reasonable degree of scientific certainty fired from the Charter Arms Revolver.”

In addition to the experts, other witnesses testified. Almost entirely against her. They included the original informant, who faced a dogged cross-examination from Powell’s defense attorney after inconsistencies surfaced between the sworn statements he provided to police and those made in court.

The informant previously implicated a different man from the co-defendant in the early 2000s. Meanwhile, another witness testified at the trial that she saw Powell leave that night with Rutledge, but when she was interviewed by police in the days after the killing, she did not mention Powell. Her co-defendant, who was already acquitted in another trial, was forced to testify, and said he did not know Powell.

Yet the linchpin piece of evidence against Powell was a cassette tape seized from her car during the 1992 stop. It spent nearly two decades collecting dust in evidence before investigators decided to play the contents just months before the trial. Prosecutors alleged that a woman’s voice, which they attributed to Powell, referenced the murder in rap lyrics.

The jury ultimately convicted Powell of second-degree murder. The 25-to-life sentence would only begin after she did her time for assault and burglary. Her earliest release date is Dec. 23, 2045. Current Orleans County D.A. Susan Howard declined to comment, saying that there was no one currently from her office with strong knowledge of the case due to its age. Powell’s former defense attorney for the case also declined to comment.

The case, year by year

  1. 1962Powell is born
  2. 1992John Rutledge is killed in Orleans County
  3. 1995Powell is released after about three years at Albion Correctional Facility on drug trafficking charges
  4. 2001Her son David Wright is killed by gun violence
  5. 2002Lawrence Rogers dies after a Rochester police arrest; Powell leads protests
  6. 2005A jailhouse informant implicates Powell in the 1992 killing
  7. 2007Convicted of burglary and assault in Monroe County
  8. 2009Charged with Rutledge’s murder
  9. 2011Convicted of second-degree murder; sentenced to 25 years to life
  10. 2026Clemency petition filed with Gov. Kathy Hochul
  11. 2045Earliest release date: Dec. 23
Dates as reported in this story

The people for Joyce Powell

Although they are technically cousins, activist Jay Coffee views Powell as an auntie. They reconnected around 2012, after Coffee’s father died. With Powell’s help, Coffee retraced his roots and developed a deeper oral family history. As their relationship blossomed, so did a “Rev. Joy Defense Committee.” The committee meets monthly, and serves as Powell’s “bridge” to the outside world.

“It’s really, to me, a collective of some of her friends, as well as people that are a part of different organizations, like the Jericho Movement,” said Coffee. “They’re not always able to be online or meet; things have changed in the past few months. Some of the members were in college that were really big supporters. Some people have moved out of the country, or traveled away. We’re always grateful for people and their season.”

A table with Free Joy Powell T-shirts, brochures, buttons and hand-lettered Rev. Joy Is Unbreakable towels.
Materials supporting Powell’s release. (Courtesy of Jay Coffee)

Coffee pointed to the 2021 Essence magazine article as central to his understanding of his aunt’s case. The story described Powell as a political prisoner who was “locked up for [her] activism.”

Powell herself embraces the “political prisoner” label, although she knows more militant activists might take exception. “I believe that I made the wrong enemies as a result of my activism, plus I was seen as disposable and vulnerable because I already was in prison,” she wrote in her clemency application,

Support from the New York City chapter of the Jericho Movement, which originates from a 1998 national march calling for the release and amnesty of Black Panther Jalil Abdul Muntaqim, provides a certain legitimacy to her case. The organization currently advocates on behalf of the likes of the American Indian Movement’s Leonard Peltier and Black revolutionary Mumia Abu-Jamal.

“Joy has been one of our prisoners since 2010, when we first met her,” said Anne Lamb, chairperson for the New York City chapter of the Jericho Movement. “She’s definitely a political prisoner due to her activism, as well on the outside before she was convicted wrongly twice.”

In the aftermath of both convictions, Powell filed appeals that proved unsuccessful. Due to the cost of legal fees, she now represents herself as a self-taught “jailhouse lawyer,” focused primarily on overturning her murder conviction.

Steve Wasserman, a retired public defender and professor at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said overturning the conviction remains an uphill battle, given the unsuccessful appeal.

“I think that it is a very difficult case to get relief on. You really would need some kind of new evidence, rather than looking at the record that already exists,” he said. “I think at this point, it is more productive to focus on whether additional punishment is really necessary at this stage.”

That is the question posed by Powell’s recent clemency application. Earlier this year, the defense committee collected statements from Powell’s proponents ranging from Columbia’s Jewish Voices for Peace chapter to the famously incarcerated Pamela Smart, and with the help of Yaffe, filed her petition in the fall. Members of the committee told the Amsterdam News that they still support Powell’s innocence claim, but her clemency application will not hinge on it.

“The clemency application itself … doesn’t depend on in any way the governor taking a view about her innocence claim,” said Yaffe. “[Powell] should also have her name cleared and have the conviction be wiped from the record, and that is incredibly important, too, but my point is just that Governor Hochul can free her today. She doesn’t need to wait for some legal challenge to play out against an unjust conviction from 2011.”

Still, Yaffe said Hochul’s record on clemency has been disappointing. Hochul has granted clemency to 145 applicants during her tenure so far, but the vast majority of those have been pardons, which are given to people who have already served their full sentences. She has granted just 20 commutations, which is the type of clemency granted to people who are still serving their sentence, like Powell.

Gov. Hochul’s clemency record

145clemency grants so far
20commutations, the kind Powell is seeking
Each square is one grant. The vast majority of the rest were pardons, for people who already served their sentences.

“[Governors] are much more inclined to grant a pardon because those are usually given to people who maybe never even went to prison, or if they did go to prison, that was 20, 30, 40 years ago,” said Steven Zeidman, co-director of the Second Look Project at the CUNY Law School.

“[Hochul] has commuted some sentences, but by no means has she used the power that she has in any sort of meaningful way,” he added.

Hochul’s office declined to comment specifically on Powell’s case, but defended the governor’s record on clemency, highlighting the creation of a panel of experts to advise about cases. “This administration remains committed to a transparent and thorough clemency process,” a spokesperson said.

Joyce Powell for the people

Powell’s age and medical conditions, like diabetes, will boost her odds of receiving clemency, but who she became over the past three decades will also factor in her case.

“She’s been doing everything she’s supposed to do in terms of improving yourself and helping the community where you are,” Lamb said.

Powell has committed herself to bettering conditions at Bedford Hills, which the Department of Justice recently ranked as having among the highest recorded rates of sexual victimization in the nation. In 2024, Powell helped coordinate demonstrations with activist groups to raise awareness about sexual assault in the prison, especially abuse targeting trans women.

“Seeing young trans women, young girls being sexually violated … and assaulted by officers — she organized around that, and we helped to organize around that with the larger community,” recalled Cory Greene, a community organizer with the grassroots social justice organization How Our Lives Link All Together (HOLLA). “We had candlelight vigils at Bedford Hills.”

Powell has also become a mentor to some of the younger women at Bedford Hills. “I’m known as Mama Joy,” she said.

“I’m known as Mama Joy.”

Joyce Powell

“Last year on her birthday, which is March 2, they [threw] a whole party for her, which she was quite surprised by, and I said, ‘See, because you do all this good work, so you know people love you, and they wanted to express that,’” Lamb said.

Greene said that Powell is a mentor for those on the outside as well. “We’ve brought so many young people to see Rev. Joy, and she’s inspiring to our community. Our family members come up to ask us. … ‘When are y’all gonna see Rev. Joy again? I would like to take my daughters with y’all,’” Greene said.

Greene also highlighted Powell’s health challenges, which are exacerbated by being behind bars. “She’s definitely a person that … even though she’s strong and fighting, she definitely needs her own healing as well,” Greene said.

Studies have shown that once incarcerated people reach their 50s, they experience deterioration in health at a faster rate than those who are not incarcerated.

“We know that time in prison robs years from people, not only by locking them up for a period of time, but also because the more time people spend inside, the shorter their life expectancy is,” Yaffe said.

Powell’s work extends past prison walls, through groups like Survived & Punished N.Y.. Her defense committee arranges for her to show up virtually and speak out about issues ranging from Gaza to anti-Asian racism.

“We’ll have events where Rev. Joy is calling in to talk to everybody who is in the community and doing that work,” said a defense committee member who goes by S.E. “Then [she] also takes the work inside and is doing whatever is needed for the different things that are going on there. I like to think of it as a full-time job of trying to free yourself and others, and that’s what Rev. Joy does.”

If released, Powell plans on continuing her activism to “impede the incarceration of Black, Brown, and Indigenous youth. She also wants to get back to preaching, but beyond a pulpit through service at food pantries, nursing homes and youth programs. And Powell plans on healing, from losing another son while incarcerated.

“I have a lot of hopes and dreams,” she wrote in the application. “I’m very optimistic about the life to come once released back into larger society. This is my sacred obligation notwithstanding the prison sentence already served. These experiences and healing journeys have instilled a new set of principles related to assisting in growing people and communities impacted by incarceration.”

Decades have passed since Powell last hit the streets with her bullhorn, yet her impact remains as relevant as ever. In 2020, Rochester police suffocated Black Chicagoan Daniel Prude to death during a mental health response, which rekindled attention on Lawrence Rogers’s death. In late 2024, corrections officers beat Robert Brooks, who was from Monroe County, to death while he was incarcerated at Marcy Correctional Center.

“I feel like I passed the baton, and in Rochester now, they have organizations that went out. I was so proud of them,” said Powell. “They had this big protest in Rochester … for Daniel Prude and also Robert Brooks because he was from [Greece, a town near] Rochester … they sent me a picture of it protesting, and my nephew Jay said, ‘You will be so proud.’ I have chills.

“He said, ‘Look, I want you to see this,’ and it was so many people outside of the main police precinct plaza, and they were protesting.”

This story was made possible with a grant from the Poynter Institute’s Women and Prisons: Covering the Impact of Incarceration program, funded by the Just Trust Advisors.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *