Judge rules against NYPD racial bias in case of Romona Moore
Craig D. Frazier | 8/7/2014, 3:02 p.m.
The suit filed by the mother of 21-year-old murder victim Romona Moore was thrown out of court on Monday. The college honors student was abducted, tortured and killed in Brooklyn in 2003. At the time Moore went missing, cops at Brooklyn’s 67th Precinct downplayed her mother’s cry for help, saying she was probably with a boyfriend.
Police closed the case two days later, while Moore was still alive. Her body was found two weeks later. Moore’s killers, Troy Hendrix and Kayson Pearson, are now serving life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Moore’s mother, Elle Carmichael, argues the NYPD used a double standard by not looking for her daughter while aggressively pursuing the disappearance of a white woman. She made reference to a massive police search for Svetlana Aronov, the wife of a doctor who was found dead in the East River a month before her daughter’s murder.
In 2008, Carmichael received the go-ahead to proceed to trial with a civil rights lawsuit claiming that the NYPD has a “practice of not making a prompt investigation of missing persons claims of African-Americans, while making a prompt investigation of white individuals.” She presented statistical analysis of the NYPD’s missing person’s data, which showed disparities in the way the police investigated Black versus white missing persons cases, but the judge wasn’t convinced.
Federal Judge Nina Gershon ruled there was no evidence that NYPD did not look for Moore, because she was Black. She wrote, “Although a jury could well find that there was different treatment of the [Moore and Aronov] cases, and even assuming that this differential treatment could be taken as racially motivated, it is well established that even so tragic a case as Ms. Moore cannot itself show a practice so persistent and widespread as to constitute the existence of a widespread, persistent practice.”
Former councilman and longtime activist, Charles Barron, supported the family during their two-month court ordeal, when the men responsible were sentenced to life behind bars. He believes that if the police had searched for Moore as intensely as they did for Aronov, Moore would still be alive today.
“I remember when it first happened. This woman (Aronov) was missing around the same time as Moore,” Barron told the AmNews. “There were press conferences, posters and door-to-door canvassing, but nothing for Moore.”
He added that it is ironic that the same judge who made a landmark decision to allow the civil law suit would later dismiss this case. “This is something that should be investigated, this is absurd,” said Barron. “This is the second attack on Romona Moore. The first attack was by her killers, and now the judicial system. This is racist and outrageous.”