OP-ED: In honor of Kalief Browder: remember his story and fight to protect discovery reform

Sign up for our FREE acclaimed newsletters!

The news mainstream media just doesn’t cover. Racial justice journalism since 1909.

Sign up

In June 2015, a young Black man named Kalief Browder died by suicide. He was just 22 years old. His story is one we cannot forget or allow to happen again.

At 16, Kalief was arrested for allegedly stealing a backpack. He never had his day in court. Caged for three years on Rikers Island, punished for a charge that was never proven. Trapped in a system designed to break him, he endured brutal beatings and spent nearly two years in solitary confinement. By the time he was released, he was deeply traumatized. The weight of those years never left him.

Why was Kalief jailed for so long? Because of New York’s broken and archaic discovery laws. Before 2019, prosecutors weren’t required to hand over evidence until the eve of trial, if at all. People like Kalief, overwhelmingly Black and Brown men, were faced with an impossible choice: plead guilty without ever seeing the evidence against them, or sit in jail, sometimes for years, waiting for trial.

Kalief refused to plead guilty to a crime he didn’t commit. For that, he lost his freedom, his youth, and ultimately, his life.

In the wake of his death, community organizers, activists, and defenders fought for years to fix these laws. And in 2019, they won. New York finally joined the majority of states in ensuring that those accused of crimes had access to the evidence against them early enough to build a defense and make informed decisions. The reform brought long-overdue transparency and fairness to a system that had long relied on secrecy and coercion.

Now, those hard-fought reforms are under attack.

Right now, in Albany, Gov. Kathy Hochul is pushing a proposal that would gut these reforms, undoing the progress made in Kalief’s name. District attorneys claim that turning over evidence is too difficult, that they struggle to obtain materials from the NYPD, and that cases are being dismissed on “technicalities.” But these are misleading arguments designed to shift blame away from the real issue: a system that prioritizes convictions over justice.

Let’s be clear: Access to discovery is a constitutional right. It is not a loophole. It is not a technicality. It is the foundation of due process. And it is working exactly as intended, giving people a fair shot at defending themselves, rather than forcing them to plead guilty out of fear and desperation, or languishing in jail for months and years waiting to see the evidence.

And there is another way. State lawmakers have introduced an alternative proposal that addresses legitimate concerns without dismantling this fundamental right. If the real issue is inefficiency, fix it. If law enforcement isn’t turning over evidence, hold them accountable. But rolling back these reforms would be nothing short of a betrayal.

Before his death, Kalief Browder said, “I feel like I was robbed of my happiness.” But it wasn’t just his happiness that was stolen. It was his freedom. His future. His life. The evidence.

We cannot let his story fade into just another cautionary tale. We owe him more than remembrance. We owe him action. The Alliance to Protect Kalief’s Law is leading this fight, pushing back against efforts to undo progress. Join the movement. Call your legislators. Make noise. Do not let them take us back to a time when young men like Kalief were thrown away, forgotten, and destroyed.

Because no one should ever have to suffer what Kalief endured. Not now. Not ever again.

Piyali Basak is the Managing Director of Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem, a public defender organization dedicated to serving the Harlem community.