Former schools Chancellor David Banks and former Deputy Mayor Sheena Wright hosted a forum recently to discuss racial disparities across New York City’s specialized high schools. The hosts brought together a slew of elected officials and experts to brainstorm pathways forward to equitable schooling for Black and Brown students.
“We’re the only city in the nation that has one single test for admission to specialized schools,” said Banks, who co-hosts the “Beacon and Blueprint” podcast with his wife, Wright, at Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem on Oct. 27. “This is a system right now that doesn’t even care about your grades.”
As of the 2024-25 school year, Black students make up only 19% of all New York City public school students, according to school data. The majority of school children are Latino at 42%, while Asian students make up 19% and white students make up 16%. However, Black and Hispanic students are the only ones accepted into schools in the lowest numbers when decades ago that was not the case. The bulk of the discussion of the forum focused on why very few Black and Hispanic students get into specialized high schools considering the current demographics.
“This is the elephant in the room. Over the last 20 years, we have seen an increasing number of Asian students getting into the schools. You see a decrease of Black students, Latino students, and white students,” Banks continued.
The podcast’s panels included Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, NAACP New York State Conference President L. Joy Williams, Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso, Bronx Borough President Vanessa Gibson; Councilmembers Lincoln Restler, Deputy Speaker Nantasha Williams, and Rita Joseph; and Assemblymember Alicia Hyndman.
“I want to ensure that we are not waiting to identify excellence, that we are cultivating it,” said L. Joy Williams. “The pipeline is broken in elementary and middle school.”
They collectively spoke about the evolution of test prep and expensive cram schools in Asian communities; possibly getting rid of the test or expanding assessments to include grades, attendance, and an essay as well as an exam; tackling issues of segregation in the city’s public schools and the use of anti-Black standardized testing, a lack of resources and tutoring at younger grade levels for Black students at other public schools; increasing algebra and AP coursework citywide; expanding Discovery Programs, which is an alternative admissions pathway for ninth-graders who score just below the cutoff on the SHSAT; addressing lopsided SHSAT scoring; anxiety, suicidal ideation, and mental health of young students around taking the test; and increasing equitable funding for public schools as a whole.
Most of the electeds at the event supported the legislative movement to repeal the Hecht-Calandra Act of 1971, which is the state law that requires the city to use the Specialized High Schools Admissions Test (SHSAT) for admission to three of the eight specialized high schools: Stuyvesant High School, Brooklyn Tech, and Bronx Science.
Currently, the city has the power under mayoral control of the schools to end the use of SHSAT for five specialized high schools. Banks admitted that while he was in office he approached former Mayor Eric Adams to do the same, but said Adams refused, not wanting to deal with the backlash from his Asian supporters. “I went to Mayor [Adams] and he would not do it. You have to understand, he’s a politician. Not casting any aspersions,” Banks said.
Banks agreed that more political pressure should be applied to Mayor Zohran Mamdani and NYC Schools Chancellor, Kamar Samuels to implement a change.
Both Councilmember Williams and Hyndman are sponsoring bills at the city and state level to repeal the Hecht-Calandra Act.
“As an immigrant, as a parent, we all want what’s best. And if you’re constantly told that these schools are what’s best, then you want access to them,” said Hyndman. “And I’ll say this, 1971, 55 years ago, we know the legislation was about white flight. This is 55 years later. We have the ability to change that trajectory and that means repealing Hecht-Calandra.”





Where are the Civil Rights organizations and Members of Congress on this issue of enrollment in the specialized High Schools? Their collective voices have been silent on the issue which has been ongoing for over twenty years. The same Members of Congress who ask for our votes and the same Civil Rights organizations who claim to speak for Latino and Black folks have not jumped into this fight. Why not?
As usual, people are missing the point, as they always have for the SHSAT. The problem is not the dang test. It is the sad and sorry state of K-8 schools in New York City. Period. Point blank. Until people like Banks and others come to grips with this, no real solutions will be found.
I attended a Brooklyn Tech that was 30% Black and Hispanic during the height of the crack epidemic. The test prep argument is a cop out. No one wants to address the sad decline of schools in Black and Hispanic neighborhoods. Going after the SHSAT is a way to mask their abject failures in fixing the real problem: so many of our kids are trapped in dysfunctional schools. I have yet to hear any real solutions from any of these so-called educational experts addressing that.
Your comment nailed it, and the same goes for other situations like the FDNY exam. For over fifty years the city comes out with a test and not enough minorities can pass the written test and it is declared racists. If you pass the test you get hired…period! The situations are very similar and the question should be the same, why are the black and brown students not doing as well academically as the white and Asian young people!
As usual, people are missing the point, as they always have for the SHSAT. The problem is not the dang test. It is the sad and sorry state of K-8 schools in New York City. Period. Point blank. Until people like Banks and others come to grips with this, no real solutions will be found.
I think they are afraid the Black students will excel … Black Excellence.
“Black Excellence Your Passport To The Future.”
“Black Excellence Your Passport To The Future.”
Joe Gonzalez, I absolutely hear you on the obfuscation of the real issue. I also attended Brooklyn Tech from 1982-85, and I think our enrollment was even higher, closer to 40% Black and Hispanic. The test is a copout- and a secondary sorter. After our children muddle through lesser K-8 schools, they the come up against a test that wealthier whiter and Asian students in better-resourced schools are prepared inside and outside their schools to excel at.
And I find it quite rich that former Chancellor Banks and his former deputy mayor wife -whose administration ended in disgrace and criminal investigation- are now opining on the issue of specialized high schools. Exactly what were they doing policy wise to address this issue when they were in power? Exactly what resources did they allocate, and what changes did they make that they can point to?
Black and Hispanic/Latino communities deserve more than this after-the-fact- posturing from politicos who claim to represent our communities.
Joe Gonzalez and Yusef Johnson, I absolutely hear you on the obfuscation of the real issue. I also attended Brooklyn Tech from 1982-85, and I think our enrollment was even higher, closer to 40% Black and Hispanic. The test is a copout- and a secondary sorter. After our children muddle through lesser K-8 schools, they the come up against a test that wealthier whiter and Asian students in better-resourced schools are prepared inside and outside their schools to excel at.
And I find it quite rich that former Chancellor Banks and his former deputy mayor wife -whose administration ended in disgrace and criminal investigation- are now opining on the issue of specialized high schools. Exactly what were they doing policy wise to address this issue when they were in power? Exactly what resources did they allocate, and what changes did they make that they can point to?
Black and Hispanic/Latino communities deserve more than this after-the-fact- posturing from politicos who claim to represent our communities.